The Fountain Overflows

fountain overflowsSo this week has inadvertently turned into book swap week. On Wednesday, Jenny reviewed Tooth and Claw, which I asked her to read this year, and today I’m reviewing one of her choices for me, The Fountain Overflows by Rebecca West.

Jenny wrote a detailed and glowing review of The Fountain Overflows when she read it last year, so if you want to know what the book’s about, do go read her review. I’ll just content myself with a short summation and note a few of the things I found interesting about the book.

The Fountain Overflows is a family story, told from the point of view of Rose Aubrey, one of the twin middle daughters in a family of four children. Rose chronicles the various incidents that stand out from her childhood—evicting a poltergeist from a relative’s home, getting to know a murderer’s family, bewailing her untalented older sister’s burgeoning music career, comforting her mother and she deals with the fallout from her father’s latest irresponsible act. The narrative is episodic, but it doesn’t feel fragmented because Rose’s voice remains the same, with its coolness and maturity that manages still to maintain a child’s perspective.

One notion that comes up repeatedly is the way family shapes identity—and the way a person’s family of origin feels normal, even when it isn’t. Rose and the other Aubrey children know they’re unconventional, and they know their father is irresponsible, but their family is so much a part of who they are that having a different sort of life feels impossible. And their life isn’t so bad. They have their music and their books and the means to help neighbors in need. When they come in close contact with other families, families where there’s overt abuse or where the children are ignored, the children is those families likewise recognize some of the things that are wrong but also see their families as parts of themselves that they cannot break away from.

This idea of family as inseparable from self takes on a different light toward the end of the novel. One family member simply walks away, leaving a hole, but one that the family immediately builds a wall around and makes part of the landscape. Everyone was prepared for this to happen, sad as it is, there were signs that it was coming. It later becomes evident that another of the Aubreys has long wanted that seemingly impossible separation. Interestingly, though, she sought her way out using music, the very means most valued by the family. Her family showed her what not to be—and also what she could be.

I’m not sure what I expected when I picked up this book. I had read Jenny’s review when she first read it, but I hadn’t remembered much about it. I think I had the idea that her writing was more complex and experimental, and perhaps her other books are, but her writing here is straightforward. There’s a great deal going on under the surface—and once in a while you have to read between the lines to see things Rose doesn’t—but the style is not demanding. It’s the characters and the situation and life itself that create the complications of this book. But it’s also a perfectly enjoyable read when considered simply as a very well-written story of an unusual family making its way through the world. Which ideas to delve into and how deeply to dig are entirely up to the reader.

This entry was posted in Classics, Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to The Fountain Overflows

  1. Diana McDougall says:

    This is one of my favourite books but for me there was at first reading already the sense of something dark and threatening just out of sight…it seemed to be foretold in so many small ways, little signs left here and there that the surface is brittle and one can fall through. Love isn’t necessarily enough and can sometimes even be the opening this “other” needs. Went back now and read jenny’s review with great pleasure and wanted to say: I very much enjoyed the sequels although the final one is incomplete.

    • Teresa says:

      I agree about the dark undercurrent. We learn enough about Piers early on to know that things could turn anytime–and we see families that have faced disasters of their own. The surface is brittle is a good way of putting it.

  2. Jenny says:

    I found the voice in this book so memorable. The part that stands out as odd is the poltergeist! What is that about?? So glad you enjoyed this — I wish more people would read it!

    • Teresa says:

      Didn’t one of the adults late in the book (maybe Piers) make a remark that there were stories circulating about men who hired people to fake hauntings? I took that as a hint that Rosamund’s father had set it up. And Rose, seeing it through her child’s eyes, would see the haunting as bigger and scarier than it was.

  3. Lisa says:

    This is an author whose name I know, but I’ve never come across her books, except a fat book about travels in Eastern Europe (over 900 pages if I remember correctly) – which intimidated me. This sounds much more interesting – and accessible.

    • Teresa says:

      Yes, it’s very accessible. There’s a lot going on between the lines, I think, but it’s an enjoyable story even if you just focus on the surface of it.

  4. pburt says:

    This is one of my favorite books. I love what the author has to say about one’s place in the family, what is “normal”, what does it mean to have a gift etc. This novel also sparked one of the most intense discussions my mother’s book group ever had. In fact she told me the other day, the, conversation continues with people commenting on the novel when they meet in other situations.

  5. Nicola says:

    Yes, it’s a brilliant book. I particularly loved the part where Rose’s mother discovers her husband has had yet another affair (although this is implicit) and sits down to read Madame Bovary which helps her to come to terms with it. I believe a fourth novel in the trilogy was planned but West died before completion.

    • Teresa says:

      That part was such a good example of how West gets the perspective right. She shows enough to let readers know what’s really going on but allows Rose to remain in the dark about the implications.

  6. Nicola says:

    Jenny: yes the poltergeist scene intrigued me, too. Interesting that when the four women (Rosamund, Constance, Rose and her mother) were together in the room the poltergeist activity ceased.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.