The Water Dancer

There is a lot to like about Ta-Nehisi Coates’ debut novel. I appreciated, for example, the way he illuminates the complex relationships between the enslaved and those who enslaved them, especially when, as so often happened, those characters were actually blood-related. In this case, Hiram, the book’s main character is the son of his enslaver, Howell, who knows in her heart that Hiram is a more intelligent and worthy son that his dissolute white son, Maynard. Howell can know this but be part of and a supporter of a system that is built on the idea that Hiram isn’t exactly human.

I also liked the exploration of memory, which reminded me of Toni Morrison’s Song of Solomon. Here, memory is a source of terror and pain, as well as a source of power that so many enslaved black people were deliberately cut off from, as they were taken from their homes and separated from their families. And I (mostly) liked the way Coates made that memory power literal, by coming up with a supernatural storyline in which Hiram is able to use memory to create a path of escape.

However, the book as a whole didn’t work for me as well as I’d hoped. It’s an ambitious book, and I think it ends up being too ambitious, exploring so many ideas — the importance of family, the nature of freedom, the power of memory, the perils of allyship — and straddling so many genres — literary novel, historical fiction, speculative fiction — that it lacks a single firm and clear foundation.

As I was reading I kept thinking about Colson Whitehead’s The Underground Railroad, which also creates a sort of fantasy version of the actual underground railroad. In Whitehead’s book, the railroad is the central feature, carrying the main characters from place to place (and, in a sense, across time). And Washington Black by Esi Edugyan (one of my favorite books of recent years) makes relationships the central idea, as Washington goes from place to place and has to navigate new kinds of relationships. I liked both of these books a lot better because they felt whole in a way that this book doesn’t.

I also was bothered by the way Coates depicts Harriet Tubman, imbuing her with powers she didn’t actually have. To me, it made her remarkable achievements, which haven’t been depicted in mainstream fiction nearly enough, seem less remarkable than they were. I don’t necessarily expect real historical figures to be depicted with absolute accuracy in fiction, but I often don’t like it when totally unlikely scenarios are posited. Other readers will of course feel differently about this kind of thing.

I wouldn’t want to discourage anyone from reading this book who is interested in it. My view is, as best I can tell, an outlier. And I hope the upcoming Tournament of Books discussion will help me to see some of the book’s better qualities that I missed. But if you haven’t read The Underground Railroad or Washington Black, I’d recommend putting those on your list first.

This entry was posted in Fiction, Historical Fiction, Speculative Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Water Dancer

  1. Rohan Maitzen says:

    I haven’t really been interested in reading The Water Dancer, but I keep almost picking up The Underground Railroad and Washington Black in bookstores. Your endorsement of Washington Black in particular is persuasive.

    • Teresa says:

      I know some people didn’t love Washington Black as much as I did, but I thought the story-telling was so great. If you do give it a try, I hope you enjoy it too.

  2. Elle says:

    I’m hoping that there’s a lot more discourse around the use of speculative/fantastical elements in The Water Dancer, because your discomfort with the way Tubman’s achievements are characterized chimes with my reaction. In many ways I think Coates is trying to do something very different than Whitehead (the latter is, as you say, taking the reader on a tour of American racism through space and time, while Coates is much more interested in the historical phenomenon of the Underground Railroad as a guerrilla network, grounded in its own era and geographies). But the use of Hiram’s powers, and Tubman’s mastery of them, is something I’m vacillating on: on the one hand, that’s simply not what happened, so it feels like it diminishes what did; on the other hand, the strength of memory, trauma and longing in this environment, especially when combined with leftover indigenous African belief systems, makes the nature and use of the power feel like a deliberate, potent, embodied metaphor. People really did escape the South in ways that must have felt, looked and seemed semi-miraculous. And a part of me thinks that Coates gets to tell this story however he likes, anyway. But I’m not totally convinced.

    • Teresa says:

      I agree that Hiram’s power feels like an important and powerful metaphor. I really liked that about it and even liked giving such a power to a fictional character. It was giving it to an actual historical figure that bothered me. Her bravery may have seemed supernatural, but she really had to traverse all those miles. I agree, though, that Coates gets to tell the story in the way that he wants, and if others find power and comfort in that way of telling it, that’s a good thing.
      This is in the Tournament of Books this year, so I expect this aspect of the story will be discussed extensively there. I suspect there will be lots of different opinions about it!

  3. This is getting SO much hype. I’m glad you’re being honest about your feelings here. I’m not convinced enough to try it myself.

    • Teresa says:

      I think a lot of people are excited about this book because Coates is such a great nonfiction writer. And I’d be willing to read another novel by him, but I’d much rather read more of his nonfiction.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.