The Replacement

One of the most vivid, sad, and frightening scenes in Little, Big is about a changeling. Sophie brings the thing with which the faeries have replaced her infant daughter Lilac to George Mouse, hoping against hope for some kind of help:

“Then I saw it climbing up the stairs. Stair by stair. It looked — what’s the word — it looked purposeful: like it knew where it was going. So I said, ‘Hey, wait a second, buster –‘ I couldn’t think of it as a girl — and I reached for its arm. It felt weird, cold, and dry, like leather. It looked back at me with this look of hate — who the fuck are you — and it pulled away, and I pulled back, and –” George sat again, overcome. “It tore. I tore a hole in the god damn thing. Rrrrip. A hole opened up near its shoulder, and you could look in, like into a doll — empty. I let go fast. It didn’t seem to be hurt, just flapped the arm, like damn now it’s busted, and crawled on; and its blanket was coming off, and I could see there were some other cracks and splits here and there — at the knees, you know, and the ankles. This kid was falling apart.”

replacementThree years ago, Jenny at Reading the End wrote a review of Brenna Yovanoff’s The Replacement, which is also about a changeling. I had forgotten about the book until she mentioned it again recently, at which time I pounced. Yovanoff’s book turns the situation around. What is it like to be that purposeful changeling in a family, a society, where you never belonged?

Mackie Doyle, the narrator of the story, is the thing with which the faeries replaced his family’s infant son Malcolm. The difference is that he’s survived infancy, survived toddlerhood, into adolescence. But like the changeling in Crowley, Mackie is now falling apart. He’s allergic to iron, and to blood; a skinned knee can send him into a fainting spell, and it takes him days to recover. He can’t walk on consecrated ground, even though his father is the pastor of a church; he just has to linger outside and look like the rebellious adolescent he’d prefer not to be. He’s constantly exhausted and ill. He spends his remaining energy trying not to seem different (even though he and his family know that he is irrecoverably, fundamentally different) — if the townsfolk of Gentry found out who or what he was, they’d turn on him.

Because Malcolm is not the first child who’s disappeared in Gentry, and he won’t be the last. The town is ruled by faeries (not that Gentry will name this phenomenon) who protect the town and make it essentially recession-proof. In return, they demand adulation, love… and blood sacrifice. This time, they’ve taken Mackie’s friend Tate’s baby sister Natalie, and Tate — a ferocious and furious girl who sees through Gentry’s comfortable lies — wants her sister back.

(A brief interruption: this is something Little, Big never really addresses. The faeries in that novel wage war, or some simulacrum of it, and they do things that cause sorrow to humans, or radically inconvenience them, but there is no “teind to hell” or anything like it. This goes against all the literature. Hmmm.)

In any case, the most interesting thing about this book is the way we look inside Mackie, and unlike Crowley’s changeling, he is not empty. He isn’t a person — he finds that with more habit and use, he might be more comfortable underground with the faeries than with his own family. But he isn’t entirely one of them, either: he reacts against the justifications and rules of Faerie as much as against his own allergens. Who is Mackie? We don’t know, and neither does he. But he is a terrific character.

The only thing I didn’t like about this book was the dialogue. All the description and all the stuff inside Mackie’s head was thoroughly enjoyable, but the actual dialogue was sometimes painfully banal. But the characterization was good nonetheless; there are small movements and actions that tell us more than any of the words. Some of the secondary characters are equally lovely. Mackie’s  friends Roswell and Danny and Drew are well thought-out. Roswell in particular, whose family has never had a changeling in it and appears to be literally charmed, is interesting: I would have liked to see more about what it takes to be charmed in a cursed town. Mackie’s sister Emma was very believable. And the faerie realm was definitely eerie enough for me. (Did you know that the Morrigan is often depicted as three sisters? More sisterly stuff, very nice.)

Thanks to Jenny for the recommendation! And, more good changeling/ faerie books, please. And, I am recommending this book to you now.

This entry was posted in Children's / YA Lit, Fiction, Speculative Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to The Replacement

  1. The best Hellboy story I know is a fairy-changeling story – “The Corpse,” in Hellboy Vol. 3: The Chained Coffin and Other Stories. No knowledge of or particular interest in Hellboy required.

    • Jenny says:

      Thanks for the recommendation — I will almost certainly try to get hold of this. I only know Hellboy from Guillermo del Toro’s film, so… not much.

  2. Anne Simonot says:

    While older, not about changelings, and not as psychologically deep as these books you’ve written about, The Perilous Gard by Elizabeth Marie Pope is about fairies (but not little things with wings kind of fairies) and it is about the teind to hell. It has an interesting alternative theory about what fairies are, a great historical setting, and one of the best heroines ever. (My daughter’s name comes from this book). It was a Newbery Honour book and is still one of my favourite books, forty years after I first read it.

    • Jenny says:

      I too love The Perilous Gard! Have you read Diana Wynne Jones’s Fire and Hemlock, which is a riff on Tam Lin and therefore also about the teind to hell? It’s wonderful, maybe my favorite of the Wynne Joneses (?) I’ve read.

      • Anne Simonot says:

        Oh I love Fire and Hemlock! I’ve always found the ending a bit… Confusing? Murky? But such a wonderful book. I am so thrilled to know someone else who’s read and loved The Perilous Gard! Some Kind of Wonderful isn’t quite at the level of love those two books generate, but I did enjoy it a lot, and recommend it too. Very well-written and kind of sad.

  3. Hurrah, I’m glad you liked it! Unfortunately I do not have a vast well of changeling stories to recommend to you. I recently read Frances Hardinge’s Cuckoo Song, which shares some things in common with this in terms of the way the changeling is presented (it’s sort of a spoiler that she’s a changeling but I can’t recommend it in this context without spoiling that!). Holly Black’s The Darkest Part of the Forest has a changeling IN it but it’s not ABOUT the changeling; it is a good story about faerie though (not perfect, but pretty good). And Graham Joyce’s Some Kind of Fairy Tale isn’t a changeling story either, but it’s about a girl who goes to live in faerie for what seems like a very short time, and reappears to her family twenty years later; and it was really quite good.

    Oh, for faerie books, you’ve read Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell, right? That’s one of my all-time favorites. It’s creepy and weird and funny and just all-around great. Oh, and Lud in the Mist! A classic!

    • Jenny says:

      I have indeed read JS&MrN; I do not believe Teresa would have let me get away for this long without reading it (not that I would have wanted to; it was terrific.) I have NOT read Lud-in-the-Mist and I think I would like it. I associate it with the Gormenghast novels for some reason. Good thought!

  4. Anne Simonot says:

    Oops… I meant to say Some Kind of Fairy Tale, not wonderful… Also thought of one more book about faerie, Emma Bull’s War for the Oaks, which I read many years ago and seem to remember enjoying.

  5. Jeanne says:

    I echo Jenny’s recommendation of the changeling in The Darkest Part of the Forest. He’s an interesting twist on a changeling, I thought.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.