The Opposite of Spoiled

opposite of spoiledThere are a lot of decisions to make when you’re raising a kid. Everyone knows about the ones that have been magnified into giant issues (cloth diapering! babywearing!) but it’s the day-to-day decisions that can wear you down: no, you can’t have another piece of candy, you had one at lunch. Yes, you can watch an hour of television. No, a half-hour. No, you can’t have video games but you can play Minecraft because… well, because it seems creative, I guess? No, you can’t have a phone, you’re ten, that’s ridiculous. I know your friends have them, I don’t care. What in the world is a Beyblade? Yes, you can have ice cream, but tomorrow you can’t, we don’t have dessert every night. Go play outside.  Fresh air is good for you. Because I said so, that’s why.

When it comes to money, I constantly feel like I’m making these decisions wrong. Should they have an allowance? How much? Should I tie it to chores? How should I talk to them about giving without making them feel guilty? Should I let them buy what they want with their money? What about the tooth fairy? Should they be saving for college at their age? At what age should they have a phone? A car? How much should they pay for those things? What about a job when they’re teenagers — shouldn’t they be doing something more interesting, so they’ll get admitted to college in the first place?

Ron Lieber’s book The Opposite of Spoiled addresses all these questions — and more — in a calm, sensible way that lets me think about them in terms of our family’s values. He points out that kids are curious about everything — that’s their job — and when they’re curious about our jobs, about our money, about whether we are rich or poor or can afford something, we should answer them, and involve them (at their level) in decision-making. He points out that the common approach that keeps kids away from money until they are 18 and then expects them to handle money well (credit cards, student loans, health care plans) is throwing them in a very serious deep end, and it’s not to their benefit.

What should we do, then? Lieber has lots of ideas, and they aren’t one-size-fits-all. Whether your family is middle class (which in the US means an income of $50,000) or well above that, or well below that, you can teach kids about money in a way that aligns with your own values. He tells a story about a wealthy family that sold their 6,000 square foot house, bought a 3,000 square foot house, and gave away the rest of the money. He also tells a story about a first-generation American family that made enough money collecting cans and bottles from the dump and taking them to the recycling center to pay for their daughter to attend community college.

Lieber encourages allowance; he encourages kids to give; he encourages them to save and spend and make mistakes they can learn from while the stakes are low. He wants kids to be inquisitive and generous. I didn’t agree with every approach of every family in this book — of course I didn’t — but I thought this was an extremely useful take on teaching children about money. It was readable, adaptable, and thoughtful about the needs of the world we live in.

This entry was posted in Nonfiction. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to The Opposite of Spoiled

  1. I saw this book the other day and wondered about it. Thanks for your review; I think I’ll read the book now. Your first paragraph sounds just like me! (What IS a Beyblade? *heads over to Google*)

    • Jenny says:

      Ha! It’s hard to keep up! I liked this book because it was so flexible — parents who want to spend a lot and parents who want to spend nearly nothing at all could get a lot out of this structure.

  2. I’ve not heard of this one (not sure it is available in the UK?) but it sounds like something I should read. We’re currently encouraging our boys to save for a few things they really want, but I feel uncomfortable paying them to do chores around the house, as I just had to do it for free when I was younger. I think it would be good to read his arguments, so I could get things straight in my own head!

    • Jenny says:

      Lieber’s approach is that kids should get allowance, but they should do most chores for free because everyone in a family contributes to the work. He does suggest that if a child does a chore you would normally pay someone else for, you could pay the kid to do it. See if you can get hold of the book!

  3. I’m always so incredibly grateful that my parents taught us about saving money and spending responsibly. They didn’t spend a ton of time on it (or, I dunno, maybe they talked and fretted about it constantly in private), but we got allowances in exchange for doing chores, and we each had a savings fund that we could deposit money into for when we did our annual summer vacation to Maine. (I always saved the most money for Maine. I’m not a fiscal genius or anything. (But maybe I am.))

    • Jenny says:

      I also feel really fortunate that I was taught about spending and saving. And maybe you are a fiscal genius! It takes a lot of work (and luck) to be independent in an economic climate like this one.

  4. Jemma says:

    Very interesting review, thank you. I don’t have kids, but I have a young cousin whose upbringing has always been interesting to me as I see the close inner workings, but have no influence. I can imagine this would be useful for me in the future.

    • Jenny says:

      Lieber suggests you pretty much can’t start talking about these things too young, so it might be an interesting read.

  5. lailaarch says:

    Thanks for this review – I’ve got an almost 4 year old, so I know the time of whether or not to give an allowance is rapidly approaching! My own education about money was practically non-existent, so I definitely want to read this!

    • Jenny says:

      Lieber suggests that you almost can’t start too young — if they can count, they can have an allowance. That goes against my grain, but he’s right that that is old enough to have questions about money! Good luck and enjoy the book!

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.