The Scorpio Races

The island spools out beneath the moonlight. We gallop parallel to the cliff edge, and beyond it I see a flock of white birds keeping pace with us. Gulls, perhaps, soaring and gliding on air currents that send them violently upward as they get close to the rocks. This is Thisby, I think. This is the island I love. I suddenly feel I know everything about the island and everything about me all at the same time, only I know that it will go away as soon as we stop.

scorpio-racesTeresa gave me this introduction to Maggie Stiefvater’s work for this year’s Book Swap, working on the assumption, I think, that a non-series book is sometimes a better place to start than a series. Her review of it is wonderful, bringing out all the good points of the novel, from the plot (not quite as predictable as it looks at first glance) to the characters (fresher than a magical horse romance makes them sound) to the writing (really pretty good, actually.) I don’t want to rehash what she says about this book, in which men (usually men, anyway) race carnivorous water horses — the capaill uisce — at the risk of their lives. Go read her review.

There were two things I particularly enjoyed about reading this novel. The first (though this may seem like more than one thing) was the excellence with which Stiefvater writes the material about the island — the horses, the legends, the cave paintings, the breathless races. All the reasons Puck doesn’t want to leave Thisby (and all the reasons her brother feels he must) are rolled into this: the bits and bobs in the shops, the smell of the bakeshop, the sand in her hair, the sense that when you’re born on Thisby you’re an insider of insiders. It’s beautifully done. Even the fact that the church is St. Columba, and there’s a real-life legend about St. Columba and a horse, is seamlessly put together: a calque on an older legend, exactly how it would really be. I thought it was glorious.

The other thing I enjoyed enormously was the growing parallel in my own head between riding the capaill uisce and the gentle art of falconry. There are people even today who hunt with golden eagles, did you know that? Not many, because eagles hunt over wide open ground, and because of the great danger to other people when eagles are looking for prey, and because of the enormous difficulty of training and managing an eagle. Does any of this sound at all like the work you might put into a magical predatory horse, risen from the sea and ready to eat your flesh at any time? Slata Baba, Dunnett readers? And yet — the joy of that partnership, and that flight!

I appreciate a novel of this kind where less is said and more is left for me to understand. This, for a book about carnivorous water horses, desire, racing, identity, capitalism, gender, and the various things home means to different people, left me mostly to draw my own conclusions. I found it well-written and satisfying, and it made me want to read more of Stiefvater’s work. Preferably a series.

This entry was posted in Children's / YA Lit, Fiction, Speculative Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Scorpio Races

  1. Jeane says:

    I’ve had this one on my list for a while, now. It sounds great!

  2. Teresa says:

    I’m so pleased you liked this! She’s a marvelous writer; her books are so rich–you picked up on some allusions that I missed. And Thisby felt entirely real to me. I’d love for her to write more stories set there. She’s mentioned that she has ideas.

    I think this is her only stand-alone book, so any other book of hers that you choose will be in a series. I chose this instead of Raven Boys partly because it’s a complete story and partly because I didn’t fall in love with the Raven Cycle until I read the second book. The first is good, but exposition-heavy. The mythology she’s building is even richer than Thisby’s because she’s using four books to build it.

    • Jenny says:

      Yes, Thisby felt real to me, too. The main characters were so terse and dialogue-avoidant that the rest of the book (description, allusion) had to bear the weight of it, and it did that very well. I really enjoyed it!

  3. Yayyyyy, Proper Jenny, I’m so pleased you likes this! I was not SO into The Scorpio Races compared to the Raven Cycle, but the Raven Cycle, it is so wonderful. I cherish it. I am reading it joyously to my little sister at the moment, and we are at a very dark part of The Dream Thieves. Everyone is in a fight, and we hate it.

    • Jenny says:

      I’ve got the first one on my list! I’m looking forward to it; it’s material I’ve liked since I was twelve.

  4. Jeanne says:

    I like your analogy with falconry and hunting with eagles, although the horse books I read in my childhood have that same flavor, of partially taming an animal so much bigger, that you can’t ever fully understand.
    One of the things this author is good at is creating and then respecting mysteries. If she’d have said more about Thisby, it might have reminded fewer of us of places we’ve been, or imagined.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.