Belinda

belindaMaria Edgeworth is perhaps best known to readers today as one of the authors who influenced Jane Austen. Belinda is mentioned in Austen’s Northanger Abbey, and fans of Pride and Prejudice may well recognize a bit of Elizabeth Bennett in Edgeworth’s earlier heroine’s response to an unsuitable proposal of marriage. In this case, Belinda is refusing the hand of Sir Philip Baddely, and Baddely demands an explanation:

“My objections,” said Belinda, cannot be obviated, and therefore it would be useless to state them.”

“Nay, pray, ma’am, do me the favour—I only ask for information sake—is it to Sir Philip Baddely’s fortune, 15,000l a year, you object, or to his family, or to his person?—Oh, curse it!” said he, changing his tone. “you’re only quizzing me to see how I should look—damn me, you did it too well, you little coquet.”

Belinda again assured him that she was entirely in earnest, and that she was incapable of the sort of coquetry which he ascribed to her.

Belinda Portman is indeed no coquette, although she lives with a fashionable lady known for her flirtatious ways. Having agreed to take Belinda in to expose her to society (and potential husbands), Lady Delacour proves to be both friend and foe to Belinda, one day trusting her with her most closely held secret and another day becoming convinced that Belinda intends to steal her own husband away.

Some readers will consider Lady Delacour the more fascinating of the novel’s leading ladies. She’s certainly led a more exciting life—she was even in a duel! But her scandalous behavior has done her no long-term good. An injury incurred from the duel has affected her health, her husband is a drunk who she rarely sees, and she is estranged from her daughter. Lady Delacour has fun, but it’s all that she has.

Belinda, on the other hand, is a quiet woman, strongly attached to her principles without preaching about them. She attends parties with Lady Delacour, sometimes even participating in a quiet way with Lady Delacour’s mischief, but she sees her participation as an act of kindness and affection toward Lady Delacour, rather than a source of pleasure for herself. And as the novel goes on, she looks for ways to bring about a more permanent state of happiness for the Delacours than what they find through dancing and drinking.

One of Belinda’s central beliefs is that she herself will only marry for love. Money is not enough, nor is respectability. She is open about this principle, but less open about where her affections lie. In part, that’s because it’s not clear whether the object of her love is worthy—and he has his own misgivings about her. The misunderstandings among the characters do get tedious after a while. Still, I was pleased with how Edgeworth cleverly holds back on revealing the secrets of two of Belinda’s most appealing suitors, to the point that I wasn’t sure who Belinda would choose in the end.

I might have enjoyed Belinda a little more if it had been a little shorter—fewer misunderstandings to resolve—but I still found it worth reading. And the final pages, in which Edgeworth shows that she’s fully aware of just how silly her story became, made me laugh. This book was a lot of fun, and I’m glad to have read it.

This entry was posted in Classics, Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Belinda

  1. Rebecca H. says:

    I’m glad you ended up enjoying this. I agree that the plotting is a little loose — so many early novels are that way! — but the way it explores different types of behavior among women and the consequences of that behavior is interesting. Edgeworth has some pretty amazing journals that I think Penguin Classics published, if you are ever interested in reading a different type of writing from her.

    • Teresa says:

      I was amazed to see women duelling! Of course, it’s not endorsed, but still… And I really appreciated the way she got at some of the reasons for “bad” behavior, especially through the Delacours.

  2. Lisa says:

    This book is one that has been on my TBR stacks the longest. I read another book of Edgeworth’s last year, which I enjoyed, and it inspired me to move this one up the list. Did the edition you read have the titles in lowercase, ie “lady Delacour” ? Both mine do, and I find it so odd.

    • Teresa says:

      This is one of the first books I downloaded to my e-reader, so it’s been on my virtual TBR a while. I think I have Castle Rackrent as well. I read the free online edition from Girlebooks, and Lady was capitalized in it.

  3. The odd thing is that for a hundred years or more Edgeworth was best known as an author who influenced Walter Scott. But that is the brilliant, unique Castle Rackrent, so completely unlike Belinda you may wonder if there has been some mistake. I guess there may be a brief touch of lady Delacour. If you want shorter, Rackrent has shorter and plenty of it.

    I will bet $3 that those journals Rebecca mentions are those of Fanny Burney.

    • Teresa says:

      That probably says something about the relative popularity of Scott and Austen over the years.

      You’re making me really want to read Castle Rackrent, which I’m pretty sure I’ve already got on my e-reader.

  4. Kristen M. says:

    This has been on my wish list for the longest time. I even forgot why I wanted it but it’s probably because of Northanger Abbey. Now I think I’ll finally get it. It sounds like a fun long-summer-day read!

  5. In a duel! How was she in a duel? Could people even be in duels by that time? I have a very fuzzy notion that duels were outlawed by Jane Austen times, but not really sure when the outlawing of them started. In my imagination it is like 1785?

  6. Eva says:

    I so enjoyed this one when I read it a few years ago! You’ve reminded me I need to read more Edgeworth, and sooner rather than later. :)

  7. JaneGS says:

    It is a long book, but I was surprised by how much I liked it. It’s easy to see why Austen was a fan :)

    Wonderful review–it’s been awhile since I read Belinda and I liked renewing my acquaintance with this early and influential novel.

  8. Christy says:

    I confess I can’t remember much about Castle Rackrent – I read it a number of years ago. But it is indeed very very short. But I’m intrigued by Belinda, especially as an influence on Austen.

    • Teresa says:

      I love seeing the way different books echo others. Right now, I’m reading a Georgette Heyer romance set in this period, and it’s fun to see how similar her dialogue is to Edgeworth’s.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s