Excellent Women

Excellent-WomenMildred Lathbury fills her days working at a part-time job at an agency that assists older unmarried women, helping out at the church, and, almost despite herself, getting wrapped up in other people’s personal crises. She is both connected and disconnected to her neighbors in 1950s London. She knows all about their lives, but what do they know of hers? Mildred tells her own story in Barbara Pym’s lively and intelligent novel Excellent Women.

Early in the novel, Mildred says that “an unmarried woman over thirty, who lives alone and has no apparent ties, must expect to find herself involved or interested in other people’s business.” Lacking troubles of her own to attend to, Mildred becomes a sounding board for everyone else. Her new neighbors, the Napiers, take advantage of Mildred’s sympathetic demeanor, coming to her at every step of the way as they deal with their own discontentments and worries about their marriage. Mildred, being an “excellent woman,” is willing to help, but her presence in the relationship is merely that, a presence—someone to transmit messages or to keep an eye on things when the movers come. Her own feelings about it aren’t part of the conversation, and although she is wise enough to know that her feelings might be unwise, she does have feelings.

People count on Mildred, but are they building strong connections to her as a person? When Mildred helps her friend Winifred sort donations for the church jumble sale, the two of them discuss the old framed photos being donated to the sale. Winifred is appalled that anyone would donate of photo of a relation, but Mildred is more matter-of-fact, noting that they had probably been stored away for years and the donors probably didn’t even knew who the people in the photos were. Yet, matter-of-fact as she is about it, she sees her own future in those photographs:

I could see very well what [Winifred] meant, for unmarried women with no ties could very well become unwanted. I should feel it even more than Winifred, for who was there to really grieve for me when I was gone? Dora, the Malorys, one or two people in my old village might be sorry, but I was not really first in anybody’s life. I could so very easily be replaced.

As an unmarried woman of a certain age myself, this sentiment is quite familiar to me, and I appreciated that Pym could have Mildred express this feeling about her state without making her seem self-pitying or hysterical or unbalanced. Mildred is realistic about her position. She’s not unhappy exactly, but she sees and understands the downsides about her life, even as she’s not entirely sure she wants to change it. One of the characters observes that some people have a knack for finding a mate, which means that widows are likely to marry again. The unspoken converse of this is that others, like Mildred, don’t have the knack. Flip the idea around even further, and you can see that the Mildreds of the world have the knack for being alone.

I think Mildred’s knack for singlehood turns up in her friendship with the anthropologist Everard Bone. She meets Everard through her neighbors with the emotionally fraught marriage. (As it happens, Mrs Napier’s interest in Everard is one of the reasons for the conflict.) She runs into him at midday Lenten services at church, and he lingers on the street near her office, waiting for an opportunity to ask her to lunch or to have dinner at his house. To many, Everard’s purpose might seem obvious, but Mildred assumes he’s looking for something other than her company. Intervention with Mrs Napier, help cooking a cut of meat, something other than her companionship for itself. Anything else would involve signals she cannot, or will not (which is it?), pick up on. Or perhaps she knows her own experience well enough to know exactly what it is that Everard doesn’t want.

As the book drew to a close, I kept wondering where this ambiguous courtship was leading. And at the risk of spoiling the ending, I’ll say that I was impressed with how well Pym maintained the ambiguous nature of the relationship, right up to the ending and beyond. You can turn that final conversation around and upside down and still not be sure what Everard was after or what Mildred herself wanted.

Representations of single women in media often give me trouble, not because they all get everything wrong or because they’re all mean-spirited but often because they focus on one aspect of the experience: the freedom or the loneliness. Or they dwell on the desire for a mate and make finding one a goal. This book captures so much more. It gets at how singleness (like any life situation) can be happy and miserable. It doesn’t revel in the joy or make simple pleasures bigger than they are, and it doesn’t wallow in the misery or turn sadness into grand tragedy. In some ways, it’s a hard book for me to talk about, because parts of it hit close to the bone. But it’s not a heavy or depressing book at all. It’s wise and funny and real in ways that few books are. It was also my first experience reading Barbara Pym, and I loved it as much as I thought I would. I’m glad the Slaves of Golconda reading group finally pushed me to read it.

This entry was posted in Classics, Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Excellent Women

  1. Lisa says:

    This was my re-introduction to Barbara Pym, and I loved it. I don’t think I consciously appreciated the nuances of her portrayal of the single life – something I also share with Mildred. I think Pym is one of those authors whose work can be read & re-read.

    • Teresa says:

      Representations of singleness, especially among older women, is something that interests me, so when I find a book that seems to take an interest in it, too, I’m inclined to ponder it seriously, and I was impressed. I’m sure I’ll return to this again and again.

  2. Rebecca H. says:

    This is my favorite Pym, of the three I’ve read so far. I look forward to reading more. I think you capture the feeling of the book well. I liked Mildred’s self-awareness especially.

    • Teresa says:

      Her combination of self-awareness and realism made her an appealling character to me. I worry that I’ve now read the best of Pym that there is, but if her other books come close to this one, I know I’ll enjoy them.

  3. This sounds really right up my alley. Shame I can’t seem to get along that well with Pym’s style (well, at least not often). I find portrayals of singlehood absolutely captivating and even though I’m currently in a relationship, you could stay it’s a theme close to home too and probably the relationship status I’m happiest with, truth be told. Thanks for making me want to give Pym another chance!

    • Teresa says:

      As I read more Pym, I’ll have a better idea of how typical this is of her other books. It certainly seems like a favorite of many, so it’s probably a good choice if you want to give her another try.

  4. Teresa, I am glad you enjoyed Excellent Women. You will be happy to know you have lots of other great Pyms yet to read.

  5. vicki (skiourophile / bibliolathas) says:

    This was my first Pym too, and it really struck a chord with me for the same reasons you note. The ‘knack for being alone’ beautifully captures the ambivalence of Mildred’s position for me – innate/cultivated/necessary/etc.?!

    • Teresa says:

      It’s a good question whether she’s naturally inclined to solitude or whether she’s become that way out of necessity. In fact, it’s something I ask about myself at times!

  6. Deb says:

    Barbara Pym is one of my favorite writers and Excellent Women is my favorite of her books. I love one of the minor motivs of the novel–the reference to the quality (or lack thereof) of the toilet paper that neighbors bring for use in the shared bathroom.

    Incidentally (possible spoiler), there’s a later Pym novel where Everard Bone makes a brief appearance and the implication is he and Mildred are married.

    • Teresa says:

      The toilet paper detail is a good one. That kind of thing can speak volumes.

      Very interesting about Everard. I’m not surprised, but I guess the question is what sort of marriage do they have. Hmmm…

  7. Karen K. says:

    This was my first Pym too, and I loved it. I think I’ve read four of her books so far and it’s still my favorite.

  8. heavenali says:

    I love Excellent Women, alhough I think Jane and Prudence is my favourite Pym.

  9. JaneGS says:

    I’m really looking forward to reading this book (finally!) later this year, and your excellent review is just whetting my appetite more.

    I like your thoughts on singledom and how this book portrays it versus typical media treatment. I also like the practical aspect of Mildred’s character–and ambiguity can be so interesting!

  10. aartichapati says:

    This was my first Pym, too, and I had a very strong reaction to the book, too. I also am a single woman of a certain age and I have had many of Mildred’s thoughts and struggled myself with whether I like my life as it is or whether I would want something different, and if I only want something different because that is what everyone else has. I think Pym captured that so well. And in the other Pym book I read, A Glass of Blessings, she took life from the other side- what happens if you are in a happy marriage but slightly bored? I like how honestly she treats all these situations.

    • Teresa says:

      She really gets at what the experience is like, doesn’t she? I’ll look for A Glass of Blessings. I haven’t heard much about it, but I like the way you describe it.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.