The Return of the Soldier

Rebecca West was only 24 in 1918, when The Return of the Soldier was published, but she was already well-established as a journalist, and this was her second book. It’s a short novel, turning on the war injury and memory loss of Chris Baldry. This injury makes him forget his wife Kitty and their ten years of marriage, and he returns to an earlier love.

Memory loss may seem at first to be a cliched excuse for a plot device. But of course after World War I, it happened all the time: shell-shocked soldiers lost memories about the war, about what they had seen, about their lives before the war. In Parade’s End, Christopher Tietjens is injured and, significantly, loses his encyclopedic memory for place-names and numbers. In The Return of the Soldier, Rebecca West is reporting, not inventing; it’s the way she uses these undeniable facts that makes the tension and the grief.

The novel is not really about Chris and his memory loss, however. The interest of the book lies in the three women at home: Kitty, his pretty, superficial wife, of whom he has no memory; Jenny, his cousin and the narrator, whom he remembers only as a much younger woman; and Margaret, the woman he loved long ago.

Kitty is the representative of perfect beauty, good taste, and order, always associated with silk and rosebuds. West introduces a note of satire into the description:

And when I looked again I saw that her golden hair was all about her shoulders and that she wore over her frock a little silken jacket trimmed with rosebuds. She looked so like a girl on a magazine cover that one expected to find a large “7d.” somewhere attached to her person.

Later, too, it is clear that the house Kitty and Jenny have made for Chris has not been of Chris’s choosing. West’s narrative voice, through the mediating person of Jenny, is not unbiased. It is sometimes ironic, and interestingly humane. She shows that Kitty, vain and false though she may be, has created something beautiful.

Margaret breaks into this beauty with the news of Chris’s illness. At first, Kitty and Jenny think her story is fraudulent, and there’s a painful little scene where they wait for her to ask for money. Gradually, it becomes clear that even though

[s]he was repulsively furred with neglect and poverty, as even a good glove that has dropped down behind a bed in a hotel and has lain undisturbed for a day or two is repulsive when the chambermaid retrieves it from the dust and fluff,

Margaret is honest, sane, and kind. She gives Christ what neither Kitty nor Jenny can give: love and rest. The two other women are driven half-mad with jealousy. Gradually, Jenny comes to see the rightness of Margaret’s love for Chris, but Kitty’s genuine claim on him takes precedence, and though the denouement of the book seems almost inevitable, it is nonetheless heartbreaking.

West is playing here with some interesting ideas about psychology. Chris isn’t badly wounded, and he’s not repressing memories of battle. He’s repressing his marriage, because he was unhappy in it, and returning to an older, humbler, easier love. What brings him back to reality is a memory from that marriage that he must face or be untrue to something profoundly important to him, to his own identity. This is truly the return of the soldier: the ability to face the truth, no matter how dreadful. This private drama bears obvious parallels to the state of the country in 1918. There could be no return to the idyllic, but false ideals of pre-war England. It was necessary to face the realities of what was happening during that time — poverty, industrialization, the Boer War, the political situation in Europe and Africa — in order to forge any kind of new society. “The truth’s the truth,” says Margaret, “and he must know it.” This is a novel that is at the same time ruthless and gentle, lyrical and probing. I will be reading more Rebecca West in future.

You can see that I’ve been reading a lot of war novels lately, what with one thing and another, keeping myself in fits of giggles, as Other Jenny would say. Time to read something different for a while. On to the Knight of the Sorrowful Countenance!

This entry was posted in Classics, Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to The Return of the Soldier

  1. Nicola says:

    So glad you are posting about this book. West is a wonderful writer. The way she describes the empty nursery at the novel’s opening is so moving. I think I need to re-read it in the light of what you say about memory loss, because I’d not really considered that before, I was too busy wallowing in West’s lush prose. May I recommend The Fountain Overflows if you are thinking of reading more West.

    • Jenny says:

      You’re really right about her painterly prose, which deserved more attention than I gave it. And the nursery becomes much more moving in the light of later events. This is a much more complex book than it looks at first glance, I think. And thanks for the recommendation! I had been going to read Black Lamb and Grey Falcon but may go for another novel instead.

  2. Lisa says:

    This is one of the authors that I keeping on different blogs, and I’ve added her to my to-read list. I found a Penguin paperback of her Black Lamb & Grey Falcon at a library sale, but it’s such a huge book that I thought I’d try something less intimidating first.

    • Jenny says:

      This one is very short, almost short enough to be a novella. It’s complex and beautifully written, but definitely not intimidating. Highly recommended.

  3. Deb says:

    There is a very good movie adaptation of this from the mid-1980s. Alan Bates played Chris and Julie Christie and Glenda Jackson were Kitty and Margaret, respectively.

    Have you read West’s short story “The Salt of the Earth,” about a woman who insists on doing everything correctly and, therefore, does everything wrong? I read it years ago, but it has always stayed with me.

    • Jenny says:

      This is the first thing I’ve ever read by West! Thanks for the recommendation — I’ll be so pleased to have more of her stuff on my list now.

  4. Harriet says:

    So glad you enjoyed this wonderful novel. I second the recommendation for The Fountain Overflows, which is actually the first of a trilogy, so you will have the pleasure of the other two afterwards.

    • Jenny says:

      Thank you, Harriet. I think that’s the one I’ll put on my list next, and you’re right that I do like to have trilogies to look forward to. They seem so well-rounded in some way.

  5. Anbolyn says:

    Lovely review! I have this on my TBR for 2012 and will probably read it sometime in the fall. I like the sound of her prose and am now looking forward to reading it.

    • Jenny says:

      Her prose in this novel was just beautiful. Lush and painterly. I understand that it’s a bit more lush in this book than it usually is — she can be acerbic — but it certainly was lovely to read.

  6. A wonderful review. I am tempted!

    • Jenny says:

      I’m so pleased — I wish I had talked about even more things than I did. This was a really lovely little book.

  7. You capture exactly why I loved this book. It is so sad though – to make men whole enough to be destroyed again…

  8. pburt says:

    I second reading The Fountain Overflows. It is one of my favorite books and has so much to say that is pertinent today.

  9. Pingback: Review: The Return of the Soldier by Rebecca West | Alex In Leeds

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.