In 1537, the Reformation has come to England. King Henry VIII is on his way through his wives (divorced, beheaded), and has assumed the headship of the English church. He and Cromwell have ordered the dissolution of England’s monasteries, with all their wealth and relics, but the forcible conquest of the monks led to rebellion in the north, and neither the king nor his right-hand man wants that again. They are seeking a quieter, voluntary surrender from the large monasteries this time: pressure through legal means, allowing the whole system to collapse under its own weight. Commissioners are sent to each abbey, probing for flaws. But from one — the monastery at Scarnsea — comes terrifying news: the commissioner, the King’s man, has been murdered.

C.J. Sansom’s Dissolution is a meaty murder mystery, set in Reformation England. Matthew Shardlake, a thoughtful but wholly-convinced reformer, is sent to Scarnsea to clear up the mystery of the commissioner’s murder and to complete the surrender of the monastery itself. With him goes his assistant, Mark Poer, whose naivete and resultant disgust at the politics he sees developing around him make a good foil to Shardlake’s more cynical eye. The characters are well-drawn and interesting, and the closed system of the monastery makes for the equivalent of the country house or the hospital of which authors like P.D. James are so fond.

I will say that I might know a little too much about this era to make it completely satisfying. Some of the historical details bothered me. There were little things: once, Shardlake went into the bursar’s office when all the monks were at worship, and “someone had left a candle burning,” so he had light to see. Yeah, right. Candles were incredibly expensive, not to mention the risk of fire. Never happen. Or when the abbot, Brother Fabian, says how good the monastery system has been to him: he was only a poor chandler’s son, and now he is abbot of a large and wealthy monastery. Well, that’s possible, I guess, but highly unlikely. A position like abbot would normally go to a nobleman’s son, someone wealthy. I know that’s nit-picky, but I can’t help it. 

There were also bigger things, that troubled but did not spoil my enjoyment of this novel. Sansom peoples his book with what is frankly a highly diverse cast of characters for a monastery in Tudor England: a hunchback, a homosexual, a woman, a Moor. Catherine’s wonderful review at Juxtabook gives a very detailed (and somewhat spoilery) description of how Sansom’s modern viewpoint can’t quite stay out of the novel, and she’s quite right: not only does he show tolerance and acceptance where there would be none, he doles out punishment where it’s inconsistent to find any. I will say that Sansom’s transgressions here are not blatant enough to ruin the novel for me, but they did intrude a little on my reading.

In summary, the mystery was good, the writing was pretty good, and the history was fair-to-middlin’. I really thank Catherine for introducing me to this book — it’s been on my TBR list for ages. What I really want to do next is read Wolf Hall, just to see if Cromwell is truly as bad as Sansom paints him…

This entry was posted in Fiction, Historical Fiction, Mysteries/Crime. Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Dissolution

  1. Do read Wolf Hall…I loved it. Without wishing to spoil it for you, Mantel’s Cromwell is very different to Sansom’s – and not at all what you might imagine when you look at that grim-faced Holbein portrait. Intriguing to reflect on whose portrayal is correct!

    • Jenny says:

      Well, I would assume that someone who could survive and thrive in Henry’s England would be a very complex character — not two-dimensionally evil, or a saint. Same with Thomas More. History, I suppose, is written by the decapitators? Well, not always.

  2. Teresa says:

    I’ve had this on my list for ages and even started listening to the second book in the series by accident, thinking it was the first. As for the anachronisms, have you read Mistress of the Art of Death? I found the anachronisms there much too blatant and I couldn’t enjoy the book at all because of it, so I’m wondering how this compares.

    And I don’t know if you’ll get an accurate rendering of how Cromwell really was from Wolf Hall, but you’ll certainly get what seemed to me to be a plausible one. I’ve been considering a reread of it myself, before the sequel comes out.

    • Jenny says:

      No, it wasn’t that bad or I wouldn’t have finished it. But it was like… here’s the black character, oh, well, you know he’s not going to be the murderer, so ignore all those red herrings, you know? And so forth. And of course small historical details, but as I said, that’s kind of nitpicky. Wolf Hall has been on my list ever since you liked it. :)

  3. I do love the time period, not to mention a good mystery, so this one sounds like something I may enjoy.

    • Jenny says:

      Yes, I’m thinking of recommending it to my mystery book group. It was pretty well-written and the mystery was solid. I think most people would like it.

  4. nomadreader says:

    My father is a huge fan of this series, and I’ve been meaning to read it for ages too. I think it sounds like a great summer read when I can really relax and dig in.

    • Jenny says:

      Good idea! And of course there are something like five of them now, so you could spend a good month or so immersing yourself!

  5. boardinginmyforties says:

    Sounds like a good read if one doesn’t put too much stock in the accuracy of the historical aspects of the novel.

  6. Androw says:

    awesome read.

  7. Kristen M. says:

    I read this one and thought it was fine but then didn’t pay attention to when new ones came out in the series which usually means that there’s something else I would rather be reading out there.

    • Jenny says:

      I think that was my reaction. Pretty good, actually, considering how I usually feel about mysteries these days, but I don’t think I’ll be seeking out more.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.