Fair Food

One of the most life-changing books I’ve read in recent years was Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma. Since reading that book, I’ve started cutting back on processed food, cooking from scratch, and eating local or organic food almost exclusively. I’m extraordinarily lucky to be able to do that. But even as I’ve changed my personal habits, I’ve struggled with the knowledge that not everyone can make these kinds of changes. In Fair Food, Oran Hesterman takes the problems with our food production and distribution system and looks at ways to improve it for everyone, not just those with the financial and geographic advantages that I have.

Hesterman’s work has a strong social justice dimension. He makes that obvious right from the start with statements like this:

I am thrilled that the country has finally started talking about what we eat and where our food comes from. But conversations don’t build grocery stores or make fresh food more affordable at inner-city farmers’ markets. The advice to “eat food, mostly plants, not too much” doesn’t help if, as Chicago Congressman Bobby Rush once pointed out, you can buy ketchup where you live, but not fresh tomatoes.

Hesterman, now president and CEO of the Fair Food Network, draws upon his years as an agronomist and program director for food systems at the W.K. Kellogg foundation to describe some of the problems in our current food system and to introduce readers to people who are making small- and large-scale changes to ensure wider access to better food.

Many of the problems in the system wouldn’t be new to anyone who’s already familiar with the work of Michael Pollan and others like him, and Hesterman does a nice job explaining the issues related to nutrition, animal welfare, soil conversation and such without getting bogged down in details that a lot of readers are already familiar with. But he also brings to the table his concerns about food deserts, a term “typically used to describe geographical areas of food imbalance, defined as a place in which the average distance to a full-service grocery store or supermarket is greater (sometimes by as much as a factor of three) than the average distance to a ‘fringe’ location, such as a gas station, liquor store, pharmacy, convenience store, or fast food restaurant.” Most of these food deserts are low-income areas, and studies have shown that residents in food deserts have more diet-related health concerns than people in areas where there are more choices.

Hesterman’s hope is to bring more fresh and healthy options at a low cost to these people who need them. Most of the book focuses on examples of people and programs that are doing just that. For instance, there’s the Healthy Corner Store Initiative  in Philadelphia, which brought fruit salads and bottled water to urban convenience stores. A related effort has gotten Philadelphia youth involved with growing vegetables in vacant lots and selling them to local ShopRite stores. Hesterman’s own organization instituted the Double-Up Food Bucks program in which Detroit residents who receive government food assistance can get a dollar in tokens to spend on Michigan produce at the farmers’ market for every dollar of their assistance money they spend on local produce. The result is double the fresh local produce for people who need it, and more sales for the farmers.

I loved reading these kinds of stories, but I also appreciated that Hesterman spent some time on the even bigger picture, including how corporations can make changes. As much as I love and support the movement toward local food, I am skeptical about how feasible it is to scale it up to the point where everyone is eating fresh local food most of the time. As cities grow and grow beyond their own borders the farms get farther and farther away. (The shrinking of farmland is one of the big-picture concerns Hesterman talks about.) Hesterman talks about how CostCo took a long, hard look at their supply chain for their French-cut green beans and made changes to ensure that the Guatemalan farmers who grew the beans were getting a fair price and healthy working conditions. They’re now extending that effort to other foods in their stores.

Hesterman’s aim in telling these stories is to show people how they can get involved. He urges readers to volunteer for or even start efforts aimed toward food justice in their own communities. He also discusses changes in public policy that readers can push for at the local, state, and federal levels. Such work might include pushing for the state governments to start purchasing food for schools and prisons from local sources. The book concludes with a long list of resources and organizations that already doing the kind of work Hesterman advocates. It’s the kind of thing that’s great for reference, and I’ll almost certainly look up some of the sites before I give the book away.

I have to admit that this book will probably be not be the life-changer that Pollan’s book was. To be perfectly honest, the kind of activism that Hesterman advocates is not something I’m particularly good at. I’m not proud of this, but we all need to recognize where our energies are best spent. However, I am glad to know about these issues so I can talk about them with people who are better advocates than I and so that I can keep them in mind when I go to vote. With a little thought, I may find other ways to use my energies to support this movement. (Hey, like reviewing this book maybe!)

As for the writing, the book is at times too repetitive and is never particularly scintillating, just clear and straightforward, which is certainly appropriate for the topic. Some readers might find that Hesterman’s passion crosses the line into preachiness. I didn’t find that to be the case, but I imagine the quote I cited at the top of this review would be a pretty good litmus test. Personally, I grinned at the dig at Pollan in that quote, as much as I (and Hesterman) appreciate what he’s done to raise awareness. Awareness and personal changes are a good first step.

This entry was posted in Food, Nonfiction and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Fair Food

  1. Ah, and I thought this book was going to be about food you get at fairs, like fried twinkies. Sounds like it’s the opposite….

    Too bad it didn’t turn out life-changing (although I bet if you had a fried twinkie it would change your life, but probably not for the better…) I did think that Mark Kurlansky’s World Without Fish made a great impact on me – especially on what types of fish I’m willing to shop for or order in restaurants.

    • Teresa says:

      Ha! You should have seen some of the photos that came up when I did an image search for the book cover. And thanks for mentioning the fish book. I’m getting semi-knowledgeable when it comes to choosing fruit, veg, and meat, except I have no idea about fish, and I have wondered. Will look into that book.

  2. To be honest I’ve nevr thought about this subject. I always have eaten fresh food, and I live near 10 (I’m not kidding) places where fresh vegetables and fruit, are available. Maybe it’s because I live in a different country…

    • Teresa says:

      Where you live makes a huge difference as far as what’s available, even within the U.S., and I’m sure it varies even more from country to country.

  3. Lisa says:

    Michael Pollan’s book had a similar effect on me, and in fact I have to restrain myself from analyzing other people’s food for them. This one sounds like an interesting counterpoint. We hear a lot about “food deserts” here in Houston, linked to concerns about diabetes and childhood obesity. There are a lot of initiatives in the schools, for both students and parents, but frequently the parents don’t have a lot of options. I’ve also noticed how buying organic here often means not buying local, at least in the stores.

    • Teresa says:

      I haven’t bought a single egg at the grocery store since reading Omnivore’s Dilemma (my CSA usually provides more than enough), and I’ve had to school myself on not asking questions when eating eggs at other people’s houses. Hesterman talked some about efforts in the schools, but I’ve read a fair bit about those efforts for work, so I was mostly interested in some of the neighborhood work and the more big-picture stuff, which rarely gets talked about.

  4. Eva says:

    I’ve read a bit about social justice & access to food issues (enough to notice and feel delighted that a couple stands at my farmer’s market accept food stamps), so I’m a bit curious about this one. I’ll have to put it on my list! Have you read Food Matters? I found that a v powerful read.

    • Teresa says:

      I would like to find out if my farmer’s market takes food stamps. They really should because there are several housing projects in walking distance.

      I have not read Food Matters, but I LOVE How to Cook Everything. I cannot say enough about how perfect that cookbook is. That alone makes me curious about Food Matters!

  5. There are also people who live in areas where not a lot grows…like where I am. The land produces maple syrup, blueberries, apples, and lamb. All yummy but far from a balanced diet. Food that is trucked in is available, but the price for fresh produce is beyond the reach of many here.

    • Teresa says:

      Yes, that’s an excellent point. It’s one of the reasons I’m not hard-core about locavore eating for everyone and why I was glad Hesterman got into corporate practices and tax codes and things that could help spread better, more ethically produced food around without necessarily upping the cost much.

  6. Juxtabook says:

    “food deserts” are a really scary concept. Sounds a fascinating read altogether.

    The food book that changed my eating and buying habits the most was “Queen of Fats: Why Omega-3s Were Removed from the Western Diet and What We Can Do to Replace Them” by Susan Allport. It is more about one’s own diet than any wider social justice. Except of course that what industrial farming and daft government pronouncements have done affects all of us – the paras on baby formula were frightening. It is quite heavy on the science but compelling if you can hang on in there with all the chemistry.

    • Teresa says:

      “Food deserts” are scary. It’s hard to imagine having to rely on a small convenience store for food.

      And you’re quite right that the industrialization of food affects everyone; what Hesterman does a great job of showing is that the poor are often less able to find ways of getting around some of the effects of industrialization of food.

  7. Sean DePalma says:

    The book that did it for me was “The End of Food” by Paul Roberts. I’ve been eating fresh, organic food ever since.

  8. Pingback: Sundays: “Tomatoes” « Let's eat, Grandpa! Let's eat Grandpa! (Punctuation saves lives.)

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.