The Beet Queen

Back when I was a big re-reader, I used to discover an author, plough through all his or her works, and then begin the delicious re-reading process almost at once. Once I discovered the vast ocean of books-I-haven’t-read, however, I’ve had a tendency to read a novel, love it, and never return to that author again. One of my (unstated! aim low!) goals for this year was to try to read more by authors I’ve enjoyed over the past few years — deliberately putting a second work on my TBR as soon as the first is finished, for instance. Last year, Teresa and I read Louise Erdrich’s Love Medicine, and I enjoyed it so much that I immediately put her second novel, The Beet Queen, on my list.

Erdrich’s novels all, or almost all, take place on and around the fictional Turtle Mountain reservation in North Dakota. Love Medicine followed two Native American families on this reservation, leaping back and forth in time, using multiple narrators and points of view, making a complex tapestry of voices and linked stories. The Beet Queen, somewhat to my surprise, puts the Native American characters mostly in the background in favor of the nearby German-American community of the town of Argus. While Erdrich still uses the technique of multiple points of view, this novel is much more linear, both chronologically and in terms of narrative. It occurred to me that this might represent a more Western way of looking at the world — monochronic versus polychronic people.

This is a book about flight — fleeing, abandonment, but also sometimes literal flight — and learning to live with its consequences. When the three Adare children are abandoned by their mother, the oldest, Karl, never stops running: he becomes a traveling salesman and a cynic. He is always fantasizing himself elsewhere and different, escaping his situation and his nature as a gay man. Mary Adare goes to live with her aunt, uncle, and cousin Sita in Argus. Her tenacious hold on everything she touches — the butcher’s shop, her friend Celestine James, Celestine’s daughter Dot — is belied by her urgent interest in dreams, the occult, the psychic, the dead. Sita, the cousin, begins by an escape to the big town of Fargo, to be a department-store model, but she winds up more and more disturbed, escaping into the fastness of her own mind.

In a way, this book winds itself around people who are difficult to love. Erdrich shows us with sharp humor (this book is quite funny in parts) how much they want to be loved, and how terrible they are at it:

Parties were to Celestine an unpleasant task. I knew full well that she only gave them to try and help Dot make school friends, and that so far they’d done the opposite. That was mainly because of Mary, who had to be invited. Children were afraid of Mary’s yellow glare, her gravel-bed voice. She organized games with casual but gruesome threats, and the children complied like hostages with a gun trained on them. They played mechanically, with an anxious eye to her approval. Their laughs were false. But Mary didn’t notice this and took no hint from Celestine to stop her intimidation tactics.

Each character blunders, hurts others, makes mistakes, sometimes irreparable ones. They are lonely because everyone is lonely, because loneliness has to be taken into account like hunger or sleepiness. But each character also finds love, in some form, however unlikely or brief it may be. Early in the novel, Mary, a young schoolgirl at that point, slides down a metal slide coated with ice. At the bottom, unable to stop herself, she smashes into a thickly ice-coated puddle. The shape of the smash is a miracle: the nuns at the school see the face of Christ. (Mary herself sees her brother’s face, and Celestine can see no shape at all.) The Beet Queen is like that: lack of control, slipperiness, pain, chaos, and out of it, a miracle.

I adored Love Medicine, and while I wholeheartedly enjoyed The Beet Queen, I think it might have suffered slightly by comparison. Still, this was a wonderful novel, and I have several friends who like it best of Erdrich’s work. If you’re thinking of picking up one of her books, this would be a great place to start.

This entry was posted in Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The Beet Queen

  1. litlove says:

    I picked up a cheap copy of Love Medicine just a couple of weeks ago, remembering how much you and Teresa loved it. I’ve never read Erdrich but I really want to. She does sound like somthing special.

    • Jenny says:

      Both these novels were remarkable. I’m looking forward to reading some of her others, maybe especially Plague of Doves.

  2. JoAnn says:

    What perfectly timed review! Did you know today is Louise Erdrich’s birthday? I love her short stories and recently read Shadow Tag. Can’t wait to read more of her novels, starting with Love Medicine.

    • Jenny says:

      No, I didn’t know about her birthday! I’ve never read any of her short stories, and since that’s a format I’m fond of, I’ll definitely have to try those. Thanks for the heads-up!

  3. Gavin says:

    Thanks for this review, a reminder of just how wonderful an author Louise Erdrich is. I do need to make time for some rereads.

    • Jenny says:

      I always feel that way, and never seem to make time except when I’m sick and am looking for comfort reading. But re-reading is so rewarding in other ways. I would love to re-read War and Peace, for instance. Someday!

  4. Ash says:

    I’ve been really interested in reading Louise Erdrich and it sounds like this might be a good place to start. I’m actually very interested in North Dakota, which makes me more excited to read her books.

    • Jenny says:

      She definitely gives a strong sense of place. Why are you interested in North Dakota particularly — do you come from there?

  5. Lisa says:

    Just in the past couple of days, I’ve been thinking about how much less re-reading I do lately. Your phrase ” the vast ocean of books-I-haven’t-read” really resonated.

    • Jenny says:

      I’ve felt that way especially since I started blogging, I think, though that has also helped me to understand that there are plenty of books in that ocean that I will never want to read. But also lots I’ll never even hear of that I would probably love if I did read. Sigh.

  6. nomadreader says:

    I used to be a re-reader too, but I rarely do anymore. I read Shadow Tag earlier this year and enjoyed it, but I didn’t love it. I did lover her writing, and I want to know more. Perhaps I’ll try this one next.

  7. DeMisty says:

    Great review! This is on my to-read shelf. I loved Love Medicine and The Crown of Columbus, so I’m looking forward to this one.

  8. Aarti says:

    I just commented on your review of Love Medicine. Interesting this book focuses on the German community, but according to her biography, Erdrich is half-German, so it makes sense. It will be interesting to see how the style and characters differ in this quartet.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.