It’s 1949 in Britain, but it’s not the war-devastated, rationed, weary, triumphant Britain we know. This is an alternate Britain, which, during the Blitz in 1941, concluded a “Peace With Honour” with Hitler. Now the Reich dominates the Continent, but ends at the Channel. Britain itself, friends with the Reich, is slowly sliding into fascism: Jews are feared and distrusted, and more and more power is in the hands of fewer and fewer. The “Farthing set,” those who concluded the peace, are the greediest for power, and the most cunning, and the most ruthless.

The book takes the form of a murder mystery, with two narrators. First, we have the first-person narration of Lucy Kahn, a daughter of one of the most important members of the Farthing set, but distanced from her society because she has married a Jew. The other is the third-person narration of a young Lancashire detective from Scotland Yard, Carmichael, as he tries to get past all the politics, the class issues, the sex, the Jew-baiting, and the hostility in order to find out who really killed James Thirkie, architect of the Peace with Honour. At first, I thought this alternate narration was going to be jarring and gimmicky, especially since the voices are so different: Lucy is breathless and slightly inarticulate and uses her own private vocabulary in a half-crazy Mitford way, while the sections that follow Carmichael are sensible, calm, thoughtful, and come from a working man’s perspective. After a couple of chapters, though, I lost my skepticism. Walton really makes this work. The narrators each fill in bits of information the other couldn’t know, and confirm things we might have been skeptical about. The switches back and forth also increase suspense. What is happening to Lucy and her husband when we’re with Carmichael? What is Carmichael finding out when we’re with Lucy?

One thing I thought was interesting about this book was the way Walton played with homosexual relationships and characters. Homosexuality is illegal in Walton’s 1949 Britain — well, of course it is, it was in real life. But many of the characters in Farthing, both major and minor, are either currently having or have had gay or lesbian relationships in the past. The way this serves as both comfort and danger — the source of love, and also ruin and blackmail — can’t help but trigger thoughts of what happened to gay and lesbian people under the Reich.

Walton doesn’t shy away from her subject matter here. She treats the mystery fairly, offering clues and working to solve the problem of James Thirkie’s murder. In one way, then, this is a particularly well-written and interesting country-house murder mystery — almost a “cozy.” But in another sense, it’s not cozy at all. Twice, Lucy uses a metaphor, comparing her comfortable Farthing-set life to a tiny strip of flower garden surrounded by acres and acres of manure. Walton does some interesting things to show the terror and unpredictability of a nascent fascist state, and the way it affects and compromises even those who might be supposed to be beyond the reach of the worst of it. As I read, especially toward the beginning, where the Peace With Honour is described, I kept hissing in breath: it was far, far too plausible for my liking.

My one real criticism of this novel was that I wished Walton had made her characters a little less black-and-white. Generally speaking, there are the Farthing set, who are not just greedy for power, but personally selfish, vicious, cruel, and bigoted, and there are the others, who are generous, loving, sensible, and kind. Granted, there is one character we admire through the book who winds up morally compromised, but we still have the sense that he “had no choice” (a term I loathe, as we always have the choice.) This was an irritation, though, rather than something that ruined the book for me.

This was a good book, and it kept getting better. It got better even after I put it down, because I kept thinking about it. Many thanks to Jenny at Jenny’s Books for recommending it, and I look forward to the next in the trilogy, Ha’penny.

This entry was posted in Fiction, Historical Fiction, Mysteries/Crime, Speculative Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to Farthing

  1. I’ve had this lurking on the TBR shelf for years – I’m a sucker for alternate history – but have somehow never got around to picking it up. (Maybe its because the cover has the same horrendous colour palette as my old school uniform *shudders*.) But you’ve convinced me that I should hurry up and get around to it. I’ve heard that the trilogy only gets better as it goes along.

    • Jenny says:

      I’ve actually shied away from alternate histories before, mostly because the only other ones I really know about are Harry Turtledove’s, and I do not in any way want to pretend that the South won the American Civil War. But this one may change my mind.

      • I’d definitely recommend some Guy Gavriel Kay if you haven’t read him already. His novels aren’t so much alternate history as parallel history, because he abstains from setting them in the real world. But the books are so closely allied to historical characters, periods and places that I *have* to call them alternate histories. The two books that make up the Sarantine Mosaic are my favourites, but The Lions of Al-Rassan is a good place to start. :-) I also really enjoyed Mary Gentle’s Ash, which is set in an alternate 15th century Burgundy.

  2. This sounds really interesting — I can’t believe I’ve never heard of it. I find alternate history so fascinating and I’m really into WWII and its fiction lately, so I will have to add this to the TBR list. Thanks for the great review!

  3. Kathleen says:

    This premise sounds really interesting to me. What if Britain had pacified Hitler? I like an author that takes something like that and builds a story around it. Sounds like an all around great read.

    • Jenny says:

      I’m a big WWII literature / history reader, so getting through this was actually a bit uncomfortable. Walton obviously knows her stuff and made it a little too plausible!

  4. Karoline says:

    I’m into WWII stuff…hmmm maybe I should try this one out. :) it does look interesting.

  5. Jenny says:

    You’re welcome, I’m glad you liked it, yay! The trilogy has a rather lame conclusion, but up until nearly the very end it’s all really cool and interesting!

    • Jenny says:

      I remember you said that (about the ending) in your blog. I almost don’t mind, really. I’ll see what I think when I get there, and probably complain for pages.

  6. Jeanne says:

    After Among Others (and Jo’s comment about my seeking out a book she mentioned there) I’m setting about reading everything else she wrote.

    • Jenny says:

      I’ve heard mixed reviews of some of her books, but everyone seems to like this one. I’ll definitely pursue some of her other stuff, because this one was good to start off with *and also* grew on me.

  7. Katy says:

    ah, this is on my tbr shelf right now. I keep looking at it, I should probably pick it up sooner rather than later.

  8. Christy says:

    Jo Walton’s books seem to be everywhere I go in the book blogosphere. That might just be my perception though, as I haven’t read anything by her yet. Farthing was the first book of hers I heard of. I’m just coming off a grueling read, so I don’t think this one is for me quite yet, but sometime – yes.

    • Jenny says:

      This isn’t a grueling read. In fact, as I mentioned, it’s cast as a mystery, and can in places be quite funny. You might really enjoy it.

  9. gina c in al says:

    This will be interesting to try along with a planned read of Philip Roth’s The Plot against America, an alternate history of what might have happened in 1940 in the US if Roosevelt had lost the presidential election and a pro-Nazi Lindbergh had won. Read a review first to see if its something you might like.

    • Jenny says:

      Ah, yes, I’ve heard a bit about this one. I’m not much drawn to Roth, but that’s purely reputation. I might try it.

  10. Pingback: Library Loot: January 11 – 17 « The Captive Reader

  11. Pingback: Farthing by Jo Walton | A Good Stopping Point

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.