The Piano Teacher (audio)

Why oh why do so many authors these days insist on a dual-storyline structure? What’s wrong with a single, straightforward story, told well? With two stories, you have not two, but three opportunities to mess up: story one, story two, and the balance between the two. Is it really worth the risk? In the case of Janice Y.K. Lee’s The Piano Teacher, I think not.

The book opens with the story of the piano teacher herself, an 1950s Englishwoman named Claire Pendleton who has recently moved to Hong Kong wit her husband. To fill her time and earn a little extra money, she has started teaching piano to the young daughter of the Chens, a prominent Chinese couple. She’s also developed the inexplicable habit of nicking valuables from the Chens’ home. This bit of thievery is perhaps her first step outside the traditional bounds of what’s expected. Her next, more serious step involves falling into an affair with Will Truesdale, an Englishman and the Chens’ chauffeur. But Will seems haunted, and the memories that haunt him form the other storyline of the book.

That other storyline, set 10 years earlier, focuses on Will and his life in Hong Kong during World War II. During that time, Will falls madly in love with Trudy Liang, a Eurasian woman who seems to be the toast of Hong Kong society. Trudy is adventurous, witty, sensual, and attractive—the sort of woman who wins over everyone she meets and gets whatever she wants. When the Japanese invade Hong Kong, she is convinced that her charms and good fortune will keep her and everyone around her out of trouble. Before long, though, Will must go to an interment camp. Trudy refuses to go, believing that she can wheedle her way into a better life on the outside, and perhaps even find ways to help Will.

Both of the storylines here have potential. I was intrigued with Claire’s thefts and with how encountering a different culture might shape her. But the affair ended up being kind of boring and predictable and seemed like little more than a way into the more dramatic war story that eventually became the emotional core of the book. The war story offers a lot more potential for excitement, but even that story was short on surprises. The biggest surprises happened when a whole new element of suspense was introduced in the final third of the book—the surprise there was the introduction of the new storyline; the storyline itself also followed a predictable course.

I’ve said before that my standards for audiobooks are sometimes considerably lower than my standards for print books. If a book keeps me moderately entertained while I’m driving to and from work, it’ll do. This book did keep me moderately entertained most of the time. I did consider giving up at one point because the predictability got boring, but then the new element was introduced, and I got curious to see where it was going. Once I figured that out, I was too close to the end to bother quitting.

I think the larger problem than the predictability was the artificial feeling of the book. The characters just never came alive. The narration has a strange sort of distant quality that keeps reader and characters apart. The other problem had to do with the structure, as mentioned in the opening. In the last half of the book, Claire seems only to exist to listen to people talk about Trudy. There are a couple of big developments in her life, but they’re brushed over. But she’s the title character! It seems almost like Lee was trying to write two stories of equal emotional weight and then the Trudy and Will story took over. The problem is that it didn’t occur to anyone to just make that the main story, with Claire either gone or existing as nothing but an observer and listener from the get-go. As it is, the end result feels sort of cock-eyed, which is the danger of the dual-storyline novel.

I don’t want to give the impression that this is a terrible book. It wasn’t! The audiobook, read by Orlagh Cassidy, was well-done, and the book’s descriptions created a strong sense of place—I really enjoyed the descriptions of the city and of the camp and of Hong Kong life during the war. It’s just that the good stuff was mostly sort of ordinary, never particularly exciting and never good enough to get me to overlook the book’s flaws.

This entry was posted in Audiobooks, Fiction, Historical Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

18 Responses to The Piano Teacher (audio)

  1. Alex says:

    Interesting comment about audibooks and standards. I have the impression that I can never love an audiobook as much as I love a book (or at least it never happened before.

    I suspect it’s because the reader adds a layer between me and the story/author.

    • Teresa says:

      I’ve adored some audiobooks. You’re right that there is an extra layer interpretation in there, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing–a great reader can bring it to life.

  2. JoV says:

    I read the book. Thought the same. The characters never came alive and I didn’t like the Trudy all that much either. A so-so read.

    I always wonder how’s it like for audio book. I am a visual person rather than audio.

    • Teresa says:

      So-so is precisely it. Not terrible, but didn’t set my world on fire.

      It took me a while to really get into audiobooks. I started listening to them as a way to re-experience old favorites and after a while I got to be a better listener.

      • JoV says:

        Precisely! I thought perhaps I should train myself to become a better listener by listening to more audio books. I am such a bad listener I think it’s because of many years of training of switching off from all those incessant nagging when I was a child and now constant talking by my closest ones.

        Why do people have to talk so much? lol :D

        I’ll think seriously about audio books.

  3. Jenny says:

    I think authors keep doing dual storylines because of viewers like me, who cannot get enough of dual storyline stories, and who keep coming back to dual storyline books in the doomed hope that they will be as good as Possession and Arcadia. :p

    • Teresa says:

      But they will never be as good as Possession! Even the ones that work aren’t as good as Possession! But yes, we readers keep trying, right along with the authors.

  4. Steph says:

    I really tend to enjoy the dual-narrative form, provided it is done well. I think that switching back and forth between characters can help illuminate certain themes (kind of like reading a short story collection, I guess), and it can help hold my interest if the characters are difficult ones that I might not necessarily want to spend too much time with! ;)

    Sounds like this is a fairly unremarkable read, however. I think the appeal to me would be that it is set in Hong Kong, but other than that, I’m not sure that much about it appeals.

    • Teresa says:

      I do enjoy it when it’s done well, but I feel like it’s become such a trend that it’s almost obligatory if an author wants to look “literary.”

  5. I read this book and liked it well enough, but did not love it.

  6. Some writers have eyes bigger than their stomachs; I just ran across that with Russian Winter.

  7. Melody says:

    I read this a year ago and thought the same thing. It was kind of ho-hum, nothing came alive.

  8. I tend to like fiction with multiple storylines, but only if there’s a good reason for them being there. They need to illuminate each other, or come together is some interesting way for it to work. It’s too bad this one didn’t have that.

    • Teresa says:

      When this kind of structure works, it can be extremely effective. I just think sometimes it’s overused, and you get two weak stories, as was the case here.

  9. Lesley says:

    I have a monthly book talk program at my library, and at the last one a patron brought this book in as one she was currently reading. She was having some of the same issues with the narration and wasn’t quite sure if she’d stick with it.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.