The Ghost Road

Pat Barker’s Regeneration trilogy, about British troops in World War I, is justly famous. Regeneration, the first novel, was a Booker prize nominee, followed by The Eye in the Door and The Ghost Road, which actually won the Booker in 1997. In the trilogy, which I started reading back in 2003, Barker looks at the war by focusing on the psychological aftermath of battle. The first book takes place primarily at Craiglockhart, the mental hospital where soldiers with shell-shock and mental illness were treated. The real-life doctor W.H.R. Rivers is a character, and so are the great wartime poets Sigfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen. These men’s experiences, along with the fictional character Billy Prior, build a picture of the war that is both brave and brutal: as we dig below the surface to discover the reason for their stammers, their nightmares, and their hallucinations, it seems an impossibly cruel task to send them back to the Western Front.

The Ghost Road comes back to Billy Prior on his fourth trip to the front. Billy, unlike most of the other men in the book, comes from a working-class background. He is bisexual and cynical and has asthma. All of these things are secrets he can reveal to some people and not to others. The only person he really trusts is Rivers, the doctor who began his healing process at Craiglockhart and who has in some sense become a father to him. Rivers is still working on shell-shock cases, still trying to make men fit to fight a war that is dragging to its miserable close in the autumn of 1918. When Prior returns to the front, the two men are separated, but they continue to think of each other as the book progresses: Prior, as he marches through the muddy disaster of France, and Rivers as he works with the results of that disaster.

The Ghost Road is less linear in some ways than the other two books in the Regeneration trilogy. Part of the book is written in the form of Prior’s journal, in which he reminisces about his own past and grimly tries not to wonder about an impossible future. In another part, Rivers comes down with the dangerous Spanish influenza, and, in the grip of a high fever, deliriously relives his own past as an anthropologist on a Melanesian island among headhunters. Barker weaves these stories together delicately: the headhunters are a tribe dying out because the right to make war has been taken from them, while Prior is in a whole society laid waste by war and trying to fumble its way to armistice. Is it our nature to kill each other? Is it our religion? If we talk about it, can we heal it, or must we blindly shock men into the capacity to kill again?

I’ve read a couple of other books by Pat Barker, and never been quite so impressed as I was by this trilogy. These books blew me away. The writing is so engaging that I could see what was happening, right before my eyes. I’m reviewing The Ghost Road here, but I’m recommending all three: poetry, murder, mud, sex, love, bayonets, cigarettes, autumn leaves.

This entry was posted in Fiction, Historical Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to The Ghost Road

  1. Steph says:

    I just read Regeneration a few weeks ago and was really impressed by it, even though war fiction is not exactly my thing. I thought Barker captures a very vivid and real psychological reality in her writing and through her characters, and I also thought she painted an interesting portrait of Britain during WWI. I’m really looking forward to reading the next two books in the trilogy and seeing how it all turns out. Glad to hear The Ghost Road is a fitting and triumphant conclusion!

    • Jenny says:

      Steph, I read your review of Regeneration and was glad you liked it. War fiction *is* my thing (when it’s good, anyway — it can be manipulative) and while I’m not sure I would say The Ghost Road is “triumphant” I did think it was excellent.

  2. Study Window says:

    I read the trilogy as it was published and this summer have suggested it as one of the possible focusses for a Reading Summer School I’m running just so that I would have a good reason to fit a re-read into my schedule. Although I enjoyed (?) ‘The Ghost Road’ I wasn’t certain that it the best of the three and wondered if it actually got The Booker because ‘Regeneration’ should have won and didn’t.

    • Jenny says:

      Actually, this sounds very plausible to me. Regeneration is probably the best of the three. But The Ghost Road is very good, too — nearly as good as Regeneration — and the whole trilogy is quite an accomplishment.

  3. Emily says:

    I’ve actually never heard of these books, but you make them sound amazing – even if, like Steph, I’m not usually the hugest fan of war literature. The Booker is the one literary prize with which I’ve had good luck…maybe I’ll give it a shot one of these days!

    • Jenny says:

      Emily, I really would recommend them. Regeneration is the best. The Eye in the Door bogs down a little (not much) but The Ghost Road is just marvelous again. I happen to like war literature a lot, but I think even someone who was hesitant would find a lot to like about these.

  4. Like Emily said, it seems rather an interesting book so will try to get hold of it in next few days.

  5. Juxtabook says:

    I’ve read The Ghost Road three times while I attempt to get the point of it. I have been underwhelmed each time. I read another positive review on C B James’s blog last year and vowed to give it another go in a few years – perhaps reading its predecessors first. You’ve encouraged me in that aim!

  6. I bought the Ghost Road a few weeks ago but didn’t realise it was part of a trilogy. I will have to look up the other two books before |I read this one.

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.