Ender’s Game (audio; reread)

EndersGameI first read Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card about 10 years ago, and it blew me away. Part space opera, part boarding school story, part meditation on war, it was exactly what a good science fiction novel should be. I revisited the story a few years ago by reading Ender’s Shadow (the same story from Bean’s perspective), but this past week was the first time I went back to the original tale—this time in audiobook form.

Ender’s Game tells the story of Ender Wiggin, an extraordinarily gifted child who some believe is humanity’s last hope of defeating the buggers—an alien race that attempted to colonize Earth many years ago and was eventually defeated. Since the Bugger War, humanity has feared another invasion and, in hopes of preparing the best possible fighting force, has been sending its most gifted children to a battle school in outer space. The primary means of teaching is a game in which the children are divided into armies and, under the command of student leaders, fight each other in a zero-gravity battle room.

When he begins battle school at age 6, Ender is immediately set apart. He gets promoted quickly, and the adults keep changing the rules of the game in an attempt to keep Ender sharp and turn him into the leader they’ve been hoping for. Meanwhile, on Earth, Ender’s older siblings, Peter and Valentine, are attempting to influence Earth politics by posing as adults and publishing provocative articles on the “nets.”

Ender’s Game works very well in the audio format. The BBC audiobook that I listened to used different readers for different sections, and most of them were quite good. The dialogues that open several chapters of the book were read by multiple actors, each taking on a specific character’s voice, and they are very effective. The reader for Valentine did have a breathless, slightly whiny quality to her voice that I found grating at times. It didn’t help that the Earth-focused sections involving Valentine were, for me, the least interesting parts of the book.

The battle school concept is terrific, and Card does a good job explaining the complex maneuvers and strategies. Ender’s schoolmates are each given distinct and interesting personalities, and I liked seeing how Ender learned to bring out the best in each one. Whenever the story shifted back to Earth, I got impatient. These interludes just didn’t feel all that important, and I always wanted to get back to the battle school and to the characters I cared about.

Card’s storytelling skills shine when he focuses on action and character development; his philosophical and political musings, which dominate the Earth-oriented sections, just don’t work as well. I think some of it has to do with the fact that the ideas Peter and Valentine present are not terribly profound and didn’t challenge or expand my own thinking much. Actually, the same is true of Ender’s own musings on what it means to be a fighter, but the difference is that I cared more about Ender as an individual, and so I cared about his thoughts. Valentine and Peter are only important as they relate to Ender, and most of what they do in the book has little to do with Ender’s situation.

Overall, however, I do recommend this book for anyone who likes science fiction, and even people who don’t. I think a lot of what has made Ender’s Game so popular is the same as what made the Harry Potter books so successful. Both books deal with one special boy who, not through any choice of his own, is made the focus of everyone’s hopes and fears. Both stories involve an interesting cast of classmates and teachers, all of whom live together in a place that, for much of the story, is kept separate from the rest of the world. True, there are no manticores or phoenixes, no magic wands and spell books, but other than that, the thrust of the story is much the same. Interesting stories are interesting stories, whether they take place in an ordinary school, a fantasy world, or a space craft.

This entry was posted in Audiobooks, Speculative Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Ender’s Game (audio; reread)

  1. Steph says:

    A friend loaned me this one a while back touting it as one of her favorite books. I was skeptical, but I started reading it and proceeded to devour it in one sitting, I was that hooked. I did feel, though, that I was completely satisfied after finishing it and didn’t feel the need to go on and read any of the other books in the series.

  2. Teresa says:

    Steph: I really do think that this is a science fiction book that has a lot to offer people who don’t usually read science fiction–and I agree with you that it’s a complete story all on its own. I didn’t read the rest of the Ender Series, but I read the first couple of Bean books because I *loved* Bean as a character. (Ender’s Shadow offers an intriguing new perspective on the events at the Battle School, but Shadow of the Hegemon is more focused on the Earth stuff that didn’t interest me.) I am now listening to the second Ender book, only because it was right next to Ender’s Game on the library and I thought I might as well get it because there was nothing else I wanted at the library that day.

  3. Jenny says:

    I loved this book, and like Steph I didn’t feel the need to go on and read others. I think your comparison to Harry Potter (even down to the boarding-school aspect) is a good one. This has always struck me as a book that would do well in a middle-school curriculum.

  4. christina says:

    Hmmm…I read the series about ten years ago or so and remember absolutely adoring it. I wonder if I would feel the same. (I was always a fan of Bean!)

  5. Teresa says:

    Jenny: I wonder how much this book is promoted in schools. I never heard of it when I was a student, but it seems like a particularly good book for teachers and librarians to use to encourage boys to read. And it would be a great choice to offer to all the Harry Potter fans.

    Christina: Bean was absolutely my favorite, although I was surprised on this reread how little he appears in the original book.

  6. Pingback: Monthly Reading: June 2009 « Books Worth Reading

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.