Barchester Towers

barchester-towersIt’s TrollopeFest here at Shelf Love! (Boy, that doesn’t sound as good as I’d hoped.) Teresa and I have had some near misses, reading the same books just a few months apart, and this time we have managed to read two different books by the same author at the same time. Always nice to co-author a blog when your hearts beat almost as one.

 

I read The Warden some years ago, and while the characters were delightful, I found the story a bit slow. It has therefore taken me some time to get to Barchester Towers, the second in Trollope’s Barsetshire series. And now I regret that it took me so long to pick it up, because I read this hugely enjoyable 500-page novel in just a few days, thanks to my eagerness to return to the ecclesiastical world of Barchester.

 

The story revolves around the main characters of The Warden: the gentle Mr. Harding, ex-warden of Hiram Hospital; his daughter Eleanor Bold; and the high-tempered archdeacon Grantly and his wife. A few new characters have also come on the scene: intelligent Mr. Arabin, the milquetoast bishop Proudie and his virago wife, the feckless and scheming Stanhopes, and, of course, the unforgettably odious Mr. Obadiah Slope. At the beginning of the novel, the much-loved bishop has died, and everyone expects that Dr. Grantly will take his place. Instead, Dr. Proudie exerts his patronage and gets the see (though Mrs. Proudie has the power of it), and he brings his chaplain, Mr. Slope, with him. The struggle for power among these supposedly respectable clergymen and their wives makes the heart of the story, while the struggle for wealth by marriage makes the highly entertaining rest of it. Trollope is a wonderful storyteller. Even when he spoils his own story, divulging the outcome chapters in advance, he insists that the whole pleasure is in the telling – and he’s quite right. There’s comedy in these pages, and scandal, and humility, and strength of character, and romance. I guess what I’m saying is that it’s human nature, gathered in the shadow of the cathedral.

 

My one complaint was about the edition I chose. I bought a Barnes and Noble Classics edition, and honestly, it was annoying. It glossed words I thought should be obvious to most moderately educated readers (didn’t you learn what a deus ex machina was in 8th grade?) and defined words in foreign languages that most people could easily guess (don’t you think you could guess that “couleur de rose” meant “rose color”?) This interrupted the flow of the text badly. Worse still, it wasn’t always accurate in its definitions, especially in French. I wish I’d found a Penguin Classic or some other edition to read. Still, I became absorbed readily enough, and forgot the flaws.

 

This is one of the few cases where I had actually seen the BBC series, “The Barchester Chronicles,” before reading the book. For once, this wasn’t a mistake. Donald Pleasence, who usually plays Bond villains, was a perfect Septimus Harding, and Nigel Hawthorne couldn’t have been bettered as the combative Dr. Grantly. But best of all was a young, a very young Alan Rickman as the odious Mr. Slope. As I read Barchester Towers, I kept hearing that distinctive Rickman drawl reading the dialogue. What a pleasure! And now I promise not to let so many years go by before I read the next in the Barsetshire series!

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Bookish films, Classics, Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Barchester Towers

  1. Sarah says:

    Phew! I’m relieved and gladdened that you liked this. Doctor Thorne and Framley Parsonage are the next books and they’re possible even more fun.

    I agree that Alan Rickman was a wonderul Slope in the BBC adaption.

  2. priscilla says:

    I’ve not read any Trollope, but between your review and Teresa’s, it sounds like I’d better get busy!

  3. Jenny says:

    Sarah — I’m looking forward to the next one! And to be honest, I’d watch Alan Rickman in almost anything. :)

    Priscilla — Trollope is a lot of juicy fun. Other 19th-century novels have, maybe, more substance, or stronger female characters, but Barchester Towers was great.

  4. Oh this is one of my favourite books I simply love love love it and so glad you do too. The BBC dramatisation was quite wonderful, Nigel Hawthorns as the Dean was superb but oh Alan Rickman as Slope. Genius casting.

  5. Jenny says:

    Elaine — obviously you and I are of one mind about this. I don’t know how Alan Rickman can be so oily in one part and so sexy in another. I guess that would be what you call the “acting”?

  6. kberke says:

    I thought I just left a comment, but may have inadvertently discarded it. I’ll summarize here, and I apologize if winds up the second of two comments.

    I concur in all you say in your review. I wonder if you find that the Thornes and Ullathorne were valuable additions to the plot or text. Or did you, as I did, think they slowed the pace.

    Finally, what I liked best about this book and about The Warden was that both books dramatized how often even smart people are wrong.

  7. Pingback: Barchester Towers by Anthony Trollope | A Good Stopping Point

Leave your comment here, and feel free to respond to others' comments. We enjoy a lively conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.